It’s an old but still frequent discussion I often have with – especially – graphic designers. The scrollbar: use it or avoid it? In my experience, many graphic designers don’t really like the scrollbar and try to avoid it whenever possible.

However, the trend for (non-flash) sites seems to be in favor of longer pages with the scrollbar at the far right (not in an iframe). This is also what we recommend in general: work with the scrollbar – not against it, don’t be afraid of longer pages, use good footers but keep the important stuff above the fold.

Facts and figures
Last week, reading webanalisten.nl, I came across research (part 1, part 2 and part 3) from Clicktale about scrolling behaviour, scroll reach, visitor attention and location of the fold. They used the statistics from their own analytics service for this research.

One of their conclusions is that the majority of users (74%) scrolls to some extent when a scrollbar is available. And 22% of those people scroll all the way down to the footer.

However, we don’t know why 26% of the users didn’t scroll when a scrollbar was available. Maybe they didn’t see the scrollbar? Maybe they didn’t find what they were looking for above the fold? (or did and didn’t need to scroll) Or maybe they never scroll at all?

I’m also curious if there is a connection between type of users and scroll behaviour. I suspect that experienced web users (and also generation Y)  tend to scroll and scan pages a lot. Unexperienced users might scroll less or not at all? I often found this true when watching my mother surf the web but can’t seem to find any research reports and hard data about this topic.

What are your thoughts?

[Post to Twitter] 

2 comments

  • Peter de Laat says:

    I have had conflicts about this issue as well with designers.

    My take on design used to be: stick with the standards, while designers want to give it a special style.

    But after reading ‘Magic Ink’, by Bret Victor (http://worrydream.com/MagicInk/) I’m much more open to custom design solutions, if they improve the user experience. I still like the scroll-bar though.

  • Looking at it from a text point of view: sometimes you need more than a handful of words to say something right. And if you need the extra space, why not use the scrollbar? Add a good header and a well written introduction to help visitors decide if the info below the fold is useful for them.

    When it comes to design, I prefer scrollbars that look like any other scrollbar. Ofcourse a custom design looks better. But it also adds unnecesary confusion. Keep it recognizable for all generations, that’s my opinion.

What do you think?